Rum is a remarkable spirit, deeply rooted in sugarcane history, and has been distilled for over four centuries. Originally from the Caribbean, it has spread its influence globally, with distilleries found everywhere from Canada to Cape Town. Amidst the vast array of options, identifying the standout bottle is no easy task. Yet, three bartenders seem to unanimously acclaim one specific rum: Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva.

This expression from the 66-year-old Venezuelan distillery is lauded for its delicate balance of heavy and light rums, aged up to 12 years. It features inviting aromas of orange zest and anise, complemented by a luscious body that blends flavors of vanilla and pineapple, culminating in a finish laden with dried tobacco. At an accessible price point of $33 a bottle, it is revered for both sipping and mixing in cocktails.

Giancarlo Quiroz Jesus, the beverage director at 53AD in Brooklyn, praises the rum for its versatility. He enjoys it neat, where its complexity shines, but recognizes its strength in cocktails as well. His favorite preparation is an Old Fashioned, which he feels transforms beautifully over the course of the drink. He appreciates that it stands alone as a fine spirit yet remains accessible for cocktail enthusiasts.

Sarah An, a bartender at Jolene Sound Room in Miami, also favors Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva. She enjoys it neat to fully appreciate its rich flavors, particularly in a Carajillo cocktail, which has become popular among her patrons.

Christine Wiseman, the US Bartender of the Year at the 2023 Tales of the Cocktail, offers her insights as well. She highlights the rum’s complex flavor profile with notes of toffee and chocolate, making it an exceptional choice for cocktails like a rum Manhattan. She believes its Venezuelan origin adds an enticing cultural element that resonates with consumers.

With the endorsements from these experts, it’s clear why Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva is regarded as a premier rum choice. If you have your own opinions about the best rum out there, share them in the comments!