Mason Walker and Clay Risen, authors of the book Bourbon Lore, delve into the world of legendary whiskey, sharing their top picks. Walker, who boasts a remarkable collection of vintage spirits, and Risen, an esteemed whiskey author, came together to create a comprehensive celebration of American whiskey culture through 100 notable expressions. Their collaboration extends beyond the book; they also host high-end tasting experiences across the U.S.

When asked about their all-time favorite whiskeys, Walker and Risen agreed almost immediately on Rathskeller Rye. Risen describes it as a personal favorite due to its legendary status and its profound impact on his whiskey journey. Originally distilled in 1983 at the Old Bernheim distillery and released 24 years later, Rathskeller Rye is exceedingly rare, with only 211 bottles available, most of which were allocated to Louisville’s Seelbach Hotel. Those who have tasted it praise its exquisite balance of spice and sweetness, with complex notes of maple syrup, port wine, cinnamon, and clove. This rarity is evidenced by a recent Sotheby’s auction, where a single bottle fetched an astounding $37,500.

While Risen cites Rathskeller Rye as his standout choice, Walker, who owns a bottle himself, considers it alongside another exceptional whiskey, Michter’s 25 Year Rye from 2011. He emphasizes that both represent significant chapters in the narrative of American whiskey.

Understanding the challenge of accessing such exclusive whiskeys, Bourbon Lore introduces a rarity classification system: Foundational (everyday options), Rare, and Legendary. For enthusiasts seeking something less elusive yet still delightful, Walker recommends exploring the Russell’s Reserve line, known for its accessible quality. He suggests purchasing a combo pack featuring five variations, a more economical choice compared to the elusive Rathskeller Rye.

In the realm of whiskey lore, Walker and Risen’s insights not only celebrate the rich history of American spirits but also make it clear that exceptional whiskey experiences come in a range of options, from the rare to the readily available.