Meghan Markle’s Napa Valley Rosé, launched under her lifestyle label As Ever, has garnered mixed reviews from wine experts. The Duchess of Sussex, known for her love of cooking and winemaking, has expanded her brand to include various products alongside her wine. Recent evaluations from a tasting panel revealed differing opinions about the quality of her wine.

Dana Beninati, a classically trained chef and sommelier, rated the rosé a six out of ten. She described the initial sip as "hot on the finish," attributing this sensation to its high alcohol content. Beninati remarked that the wine doesn’t convey the essence of being made with care from family-owned vineyards, suggesting instead it feels like a product created by "expert marketers" rather than Markle herself.

Conversely, Crystl Faye Horton, former wine director at Del Frisco’s Double Eagle Steakhouse, praised the rosé. She noted the wine’s robust flavor profile and deemed it a good value at $30, indicating that it appears to be crafted with intention and seriousness.

The contrasting feedback highlights the ongoing debate about Markle’s foray into winemaking, with some experts questioning the authenticity of the product while others see potential and quality in her offerings.