In a notable achievement for comedian Jim Gaffigan, his bourbon brand, Fathertime Bourbon, has been awarded Best New Bourbon at the 2026 San Francisco World Spirits Competition for its product, The Caboose: Empty Nester Strength. This bourbon received an impressive score of 97 points, clinching a Double Gold Medal in recognition of its quality.

Fathertime was co-founded by Gaffigan and his friend, film producer Stu Pollard, in 2024. The brand’s offerings are creatively inspired by Gaffigan’s five children and include names like Firstborn Edition, Second Child Syndrome, and, of course, The Caboose. The Caboose: Empty Nester Strength is a Kentucky straight bourbon presented at a robust 121 proof, making it the fifth release in their lineup.

Gaffigan has established himself as a figure in the whiskey community, participating in whiskey-focused podcasts and events. Additionally, he has presented a bourbon-themed stand-up special titled “The Bourbon Set,” in collaboration with Old Forester.

Describing the bourbon, Gaffigan admits, “I’m (obviously) not a bourbon expert… but I did my research, and I know what I like.” He mentions that he hand-selected the bourbon and personally signed each bottle. Fathertime operates independently without backing from major spirit companies.

The Caboose’s unique recipe is crafted from 63% corn, 30% rye, and 7% malted barley, coming from undisclosed Kentucky distilleries. It’s offered in two proof points, with The Caboose: Empty Nester Strength priced at around $200.

Judges at the competition highlighted The Caboose’s remarkable aroma, noting hints of matcha tea, ginger, cookies, and lemon peel. They appreciated a palate filled with flavors like graham cracker, marshmallow, dried fig, and fruitcake, rounded off with an unexpected bubble gum note, leading to its high score.

To qualify for Best New Bourbon, products must be either newly launched within the past four years or fully reformulated versions of existing brands, achieving a minimum score of 96 points. The judges’ recognition reflects the bourbon’s standout qualities and craftsmanship.

For bourbon enthusiasts and Gaffigan fans alike, this recognition marks an exciting moment in the ever-growing whiskey industry, with Fathertime Bourbon now firmly established on the map.